The Walking Dead: Rick’s Early Death Was Supposed to Set Up Carl vs. Shane

The Walking Dead’s deluxe edition reveals that the comic writer Robert Kirkman was going to use the shocking death of Rick Grimes to set his son, Carl Grimes, rivalry with Shane. It is no secret that Kirkman was planning to kill Rick early, and he was thinking of Shane to kill Rick when they went to talk in Issue #6. In continuity, Rick returned to his wife Lori Grimes and couldn’t get over Lori and Shane’s affair. Shane went to kill Rick, but Carl came out of nowhere and shot Shane.

As the deluxe edition of Kirkman is out now, it reveals that if Shane had killed Rick here, then it would have set up Shane and Carl’s rivalry. Kirkman admits that he had room to tell a long story of Carl’s revenge on Shane. Kirkman was planning that Carl would stumble into the woods and see Shane killing Rick. Carl would realize that Shane was pretending to be a good guy was all a lie.

The focus of the book would have shifted to Carl Grimes, and after seeing Shane killing Rick, Carl would be afraid to tell his mother what he saw in the woods. He would think that Shane would kill Lori too so, he would have kept quiet. Moreover, Shane would become the first villain of the novel, and he wouldn’t know that Carl knows what he did to Rick. In the comics, it would have added more tension and drama and as the story progressed, Carl would have set up a cat and mouse game. He would find a way to get Shane to get killed by zombies or even worse.

It would lead to a civil war between Shane’s followers and Carl. Later on, Carl would slip into Rick’s shoes and make his way up to Commonwealth. It would have made him more strong, and his mother and baby sister would be alive as well. The ending story of the Old Man Carl would fit the plot because he would become the protagonist of the book who has seen the old world transform into a new one. The book would have connected the younger audience too, especially when his romance was budding with Lydia and getting torn between becoming a leader.


The fans of the series would have hated Andrew Lincoln’s character dying because he became their favorite since episode 1. If Shane would have survived, then Carl would have killed Daryl and him, and become the Alpha of the pack. However, Carl Grimes was too young to lead the series. Ultimately, it is too hard to see the Walking Dead series without the charming Lincoln, creating the early foundation for the alliance before he left.

Keep checking back with us for more news related to The Walking Dead series and book.

Manisha Puri
A passionate ink singer with the idea of sharing the new vision and different perspectives on various concepts and thoughts in good reads. Also, aims for spreading the word with the best SEO techniques. 


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Warner Bros. Will Pay Filmmakers for HBO Max Releases

Recently, Warner Bros. decided to release all its 2021 movies on HBO Max on the same day as their cinematical releases. After...

The Walking Dead: Rick’s Early Death Was Supposed to Set Up Carl vs. Shane

The Walking Dead's deluxe edition reveals that the comic writer Robert Kirkman was going to use the shocking death of Rick Grimes...

The Boys Actor Antony Starr Confirms Season 3’s Production Starts Soon

It’s been only some days since we stepped into 2021, and it seems like it is going to be a great year...

WandaVision Surpasses Avengers: Endgame in VFX Shots

Recently, WandaVision actor Paul Bettany claimed that the upcoming Marvel series is bigger than the Avengers: Endgame in one aspect. Sources reveal...

Every Crunchyroll Original Anime Launched in 2020, Ranked From Worst to Best

2020 was not a great year for us, but it was for Crunchyroll. The company created and launched seven animes, which received...